Transcript
Best Practice SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures
31 August, 2002
Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Developed by: Hisham Abu-Adas Developed: July, 2002 Civil Engineering Unit/M&CED Consulting Services Department
Previous Issue: New
Next Planned Update: 1 September, 2007 Page 1 of 39
Primary contact: Abu-Adas, Hisham on phone 874-6908
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Table of Contents 1
2
3
4
Page Introduction .............................................................................................. 3 1.1
Purpose ............................................................................................ 3
1.2
Scope ............................................................................................... 3
1.3
Disclaimer......................................................................................... 3
1.4
Conflicts with Mandatory Standards ................................................. 3
References............................................................................................... 4 2.1
Saudi Aramco References................................................................ 4
2.2
Industry Codes and Standards ......................................................... 4
General .................................................................................................... 4 3.2
Wind Speed V................................................................................... 4
3.3
Importance Factor I .......................................................................... 4
3.4
Exposure Category........................................................................... 4
3.5
Basic ASCE 7 Formulas ................................................................... 5
3.6
Velocity Pressure qz.......................................................................... 5
3.7
Gust Effect Factors G ....................................................................... 6
3.8
Force Coefficient Cf .......................................................................... 6
3.9
Projected Area Ae ............................................................................. 6
Wind Loads on Pipe Racks & Open Frame Structures ........................... 6 4.1
Piperacks.......................................................................................... 6
4.2
Open Frame Structures .................................................................... 8
ATTACHMENTS: Attachment 1 – List of Tables 1. Basic Wind Speed V for Saudi Aramco Sites 2. Velocity Pressure qz (Customary Units) 3. Velocity Pressure qz (Metric Units) Attachment 2: ................................................................................................. 22
Example 1 – Wind Load on Piperack Attachment 3: ................................................................................................. 26
Example 2 – Wind Load on Piperack Attachment 4 .................................................................................................. 31
Example 3 – Wind Load on Open Frame Structure Page 2 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
1
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Introduction Most of the design practices in the petrochemical industry were based on the wind loading provisions of ASCE 7, “Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and Other Structures” or its predecessor (ANSI A58.1). ASCE 7 does not adequately address Piperacks and Open Frame Structures. It is the intent of this practice to provide uniform application of practices to all Piperacks and Open Frame Structures designed for Saudi Aramco projects. 1.1
Purpose The purpose of this practice is to provide the engineer and designer with guidelines for wind load on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures for use by engineers working on Saudi Aramco projects and Saudi Aramco engineers.
1.2
Scope This design guideline covers the minimum requirements and provides guidance for calculating wind load on onshore Piperacks and Open Frame Structures typically located in petrochemical facilities. Section 2.0 of this instruction includes reference codes, Saudi Aramco standards, and specifications. In cases where this guideline conflicts with these references, the conflict shall be immediately brought to the attention of the project engineer.
1.3
Disclaimer The material in this Best Practices document provides the most correct and accurate design guidelines available to Saudi Aramco which comply with international industry practices. This material is being provided for the general guidance and benefit of the Designer. Use of the Best Practices in designing projects for Saudi Aramco, however, does not relieve the Designer from his responsibility to verify the accuracy of any information presented or from his contractual liability to provide safe and sound designs that conform to Mandatory Saudi Aramco Engineering Requirements. Use of the information or material contained herein is no guarantee that the resulting product will satisfy the applicable requirements of any project. Saudi Aramco assumes no responsibility or liability whatsoever for any reliance on the information presented herein or for designs prepared by Designers in accordance with the Best Practices. Use of the Best Practices by Designers is intended solely for, and shall be strictly limited to, Saudi Aramco projects. Saudi Aramco® is a registered trademark of the Saudi Arabian Oil Company. Copyright, Saudi Aramco, 2002.
Page 3 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
1.4
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Conflicts with Mandatory Standards In the event of a conflict between this Best Practice and other Mandatory Saudi Aramco Engineering Requirement, the Mandatory Saudi Aramco Engineering Requirement shall govern.
2
References This Best Practice is based on the latest edition of the references below, unless otherwise noted. Short titles will be used herein when appropriate. Short titles will be used herein when appropriate. 2.1
Saudi Aramco References Saudi Aramco Engineering Standards (SAES)
2.2
SAES-A-112
Meteorological and Seismic Design Data
SAES-M-001
Structural Design Criteria for non-Building Structures
Industry Codes and Standards American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) ASCE 7 – 95
Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and Other Structures
Wind Load and Anchor Bolt Design for Petrochemical Facilities 3
General 3.1
Wind loads shall be computed and applied in accordance with SAES-M-001, ASCE 7-, and the recommended guidelines for Piperacks, and Open Frame Structure in ASCE’s “Wind loads and Anchor Bolt Design for Petrochemical Facilities”.
3.2
Wind load calculations shall be based on basic wind speed V of 3-second gust speed at 33 ft (10 m) above the ground in Exposure C and associated with an annual probability 0.02 of being equaled or exceeded (50-year mean recurrence interval). The basic wind speed V for each site is defined in SAES-A-112, “Meteorological and Seismic Design Data” and Table 1 (Attachment 1).
3.3
The Importance Factor I shall be category IV.
3.4
Exposure Category C shall be used, except for structures close to the shoreline, as defined in ASCE, where Exposure Category D shall be used. Exposure D is defined as ‘Flat, unobstructed areas exposed to wind flowing over open water Page 4 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
for a distance of at least 1 mi 91.61 km). The Exposure category for each site is defined in SAES-A-112, “Meteorological and Seismic Design Data”. 3.5
Basic ASCE 7 Formulas The design wind forces for the main wind force resisting system shall be per Table 6-1 (ASCE 7) for “Open Buildings and Other Structures”. The applied wind force F shall be determined by the basic equation: F = qz G Cf Ae
ASCE 7 Table 6-1
where qz = Velocity pressure at height z above ground G = Gust response factor Cf = Force coefficient Ae = Projected area normal to wind 3.6
Velocity Pressure qz The velocity pressure qz is determined in accordance with the provisions of Section 6.5 of ASCE 7. qz = 0.00256 Kz Kzt V2 I (lb/sq ft)ASCE 7 (Eq. 6-1) qz = 0.613 Kz Kzt V2 I (N/m2) [SI Units] where Kz is given in Table 6-3 of ASCE 7. Kzt as per provisions of 6.5.5 of ASCE 7. Kzt is equal to 1.0 for Piperacks and Open Frame Structures located in Saudi Aramco facilities. V is basic wind speed of 3-second gust speed at 33 ft above the ground. I is the Importance Factor set forth in Table 6-2 of ASCE 7. I equal 1.15 for Category IV structures. All Piperacks and Open Frame Structures at Saudi Aramco facilities are considered Category IV structures. Velocity pressures qz are determined using ASCE 7, Eq. 6-1 shown above. Attachment 1 - Tables 2 (Customary Units) and 3 (Metric Units) provides values for qz at several heights for most Saudi Aramco sites. These values are to be used for Piperacks and Open Frame Structures.
Page 5 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
3.7
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Gust Effect Factors G The gust effect factor G is determined in accordance with the provisions of Table 6-1 and Section 6.6 of ASCE 7. For rigid structures, the simplified method of section 6.6.1 specifies G=0.85 for structures in terrain exposure C and D. This value should be used for all Piperacks and Open Frame Structures. For flexible or dynamically sensitive structures Gf is used in place of G. Flexible structures defined by ASCE 7 as those structures with a fundamental frequency f < 1 Hz or if the height divided by least horizontal dimension is greater than 4. Gf shall be calculated by a rational method as given in ASCE 7 Commentary Section 6.6.
3.8
Force Coefficient Cf The force coefficient Cf for the various structures shall be as listed in the following sections of this guideline.
3.9
Projected Area Ae The projected area Ae normal to wind direction for the various structures in question shall be as defined in this guideline.
4
Wind Loads on Pipe Racks & Open Frame Structures 4.1
Piperacks Wind on the piperack structure itself should be calculated based on no shielding. For all structural members Cf = 1.8 shall be used, except Cf = 2.0 shall be used for columns. 4.1.1
Tributary Area for Piping The tributary area for piping should be based on the diameter of the largest pipe plus 10% of the width of the pipe rack. This sum is multiplied by the length of the pipes (bent spacing) to determine the tributary area.
4.1.2
Tributary Area for Cable Trays The tributary area for cable trays should be based on the height of the largest tray plus 10% of the width of the pipe rack. This sum is multiplied by the length of the pipes (bent spacing) to determine the tributary area.
Page 6 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
4.1.3
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Force Coefficients for Pipes The force coefficient Cf = 0.7 should be used as a minimum. The force coefficient Cf is taken from ASCE 7, Table 6-7 (see below) for a round shape, with h/D=25, D√qz > 2.5 and a moderately smooth surface; that is Cf = 0.7. If the largest pipe is insulated, then consider using a Cf for a rough pipe dependent on the roughness coefficient of the insulation (D′/d).
Table 6-7 – (Adapted from ASCE 7)
Page 7 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
4.1.4
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Force Coefficients for Cable Trays For cable trays the force coefficient Cf = 2.0 shall be used. The force coefficient Cf, for cable trays is taken from ASCE 7, Table 6-7 for a square shape with the face normal to the wind and with h/D = 25; that is Cf = 2.0.
4.2
Open Frame Structures 4.2.1
General Wind loads should be calculated in accordance with the general procedures and provisions of ASCE 7 for wind loads on “Other Structures”. 4.2.1.1
Main Wind Force Resisting System Wind forces acting on structural frame and appurtenances (ladders, handrails, stairs, etc.) should be computed in accordance with 4.2.1.2 and 4.2.2. Wind forces on piping and cable trays located on or attached to the structure should be calculated according to the provisions of 4.1 and added to the wind forces acting on the frames in accordance with 4.2.6.
4.2.1.2
Force Coefficients for Components Wind loads for the design of individual components, cladding, and appurtenances (excluding vessels, piping and cable trays) should be calculated according to the provisions of ASCE 7. Force coefficients for several items are given in Table 4.1 below.
TABLE 4.1 Force Coefficients for Wind Loads on Components (Adapted from ASCE – “Wind Loads and Anchor Bolt Design for Petrochemical Facilities”) Item Handrail Ladder without cage Ladder with cage Solid Rectangles & Flat Plates Stair w/handrail Side Elevation End elevation Round or Square Shapes
Cf 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0
Projected Area 0.80 sq. ft./ft. 0.50 sq. ft./ft. 0.75 sq. ft./ft. Handrail area plus channel depth 50% gross area
2.0 See ASCE 7 Table 6-7
Page 8 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
4.2.2
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Frame Load 4.2.2.1
Design wind forces for the main wind force resisting system for open frame structure should be determined by the equation: Fs = qz G Cf Ae
ASCE 7 Table 6-1
(Eq. 4.1a)
where Fs is the wind force on structural frame and appurtenance qz as defined in Section 3.6 G as defined in Section 3.7 Cf the force coefficient is determined from the provisions of 4.2.3 Ae is the area of application of force as determined per 4.2.5 The design load cases are computed per 4.2.6 The structure is idealized as two sets of orthogonal frames. The maximum wind force on each set of frames is calculated independently. Note: Cf accounts for the entire structure in the direction of the wind. 4.2.2.2
Limitation of Analytical Procedure Design wind forces are calculated for the structure as a whole. The method is described for structure, which are rectangular in plan and elevation.
4.2.3
Force Coefficients Cf The force coefficient for a set of frames shall be calculated by Cf = CDg / ε
(Eq. 4-2)
where CDg is the force coefficient for the set of frames given in Figure 4.1, and ε is the solidity ratio calculated in accordance with 4.2.4. Force coefficients are defined for wind forces acting normal to the wind frames irrespective of the actual wind direction. Page 9 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
(Adapted from ASCE “Wind Loads and Anchor Bolt Design for Petrochemical Facilities”)
Page 10 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
(Adapted from ASCE “Wind Loads and Anchor Bolt Design for Petrochemical Facilities”)
Page 11 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
(Adapted from ASCE “Wind Loads and Anchor Bolt Design for Petrochemical Facilities”)
Page 12 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
(Adapted from ASCE “Wind Loads and Anchor Bolt Design for Petrochemical Facilities”)
Page 13 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
(Adapted from ASCE “Wind Loads and Anchor Bolt Design for Petrochemical Facilities”)
Page 14 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
4.2.4
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Solidity Ratio ε ε = As / Ag
(Eq. 4-3)
where Ag is the gross area of the windward frame and As is the effective solid area of the windward frame defined by the following:
4.2.5
a)
The solid area of a frame is defined as the solid area of each element in the plane of the frame projected normal to the nominal wind direction. Elements considered as part of the solid area of a frame include beams, columns, bracing, cladding, stairs, ladders, handrails, etc. Items such as vessels, tanks, piping and cable trays are not included in calculations of solid area of frame; wind load on these items are calculated separately.
b)
The presence of flooring or decking does not cause an increase of the solid area beyond the inclusion of the thickness of the deck.
c)
For structures with frames of equal solidity, the effective solid area As should be taken as solid area of the windward frame.
d)
For structures where the solid area of the windward frame exceeds the solid area of the other frames, the effective solid area As should be taken as the solid area of the windward frame.
e)
For structures where the solid area of the windward frame is less than the solid area of the other frames, the effective solid area As should be taken as the average of all the frames.
Area of Application of Force Ae shall be calculated in the same manner as the effective solid area in 4.2.4 except that it is for the portion of the structure height consistent with the velocity pressure qz.
4.2.6
Design Load Cases •
The total wind force acting on the structure in a given direction, FT, is equal to the sum of the wind load acting on the structure and appurtenances (Fs), plus the wind load on the equipment and vessels,
Page 15 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
plus the wind load on piping. See Figure 4.2 for complete definitions of FT and FS. •
If piping arrangements are not known, the engineer may assume the piping area to be 10% of the gross area of the face of the structure for each principal axis. A force coefficient of 0.7 should be used for this piping area.
The following two load cases must be considered as a minimum: •
Frame load + equipment load + piping load (FT) for one axis, acting simultaneously with 50% of the frame load (FS) along other axis, for each direction. These two combinations are indicated in Figure 4.2.
(Adapted from ASCE “Wind Loads and Anchor Bolt Design for Petrochemical Facilities”)
31 August, 2002
Revision Summary New Saudi Aramco Best Design Practice.
Page 16 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
TABLE 1: Basic Wind Speed - 3-sec. Gust per SAES-A-112 Site Location Abha Abqaiq Al-Jauf Ar'ar Berri Dhahran Duba Hawiyah Haradh Hawtah Hofuf Jeddah Jizan Ju'aymah Khamis Mushayt Khurais Medina Najran Qasim Qaisumah Qatif Rabigh Ras Tanura Riyadh Safaniya Shaybah Shedgum Tanajib Tabuk Turaif Udhailiyah Uthmaniyah Yanbu
Miles per hour mph
Kilometer per hour km/hr
93 93 103 112 93 93 96 93 93 96 93 93 96 93 93 101 96 93 119 114 93 93 93 103 96 96 96 96 106 103 96 96 93
150 150 165 181 150 150 155 150 150 154 150 150 155 150 150 163 155 150 191 183 150 150 150 165 155 155 155 155 171 165 155 155 150
Page 17 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Page 18 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Page 19 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Page 20 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Page 21 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Attachment 2 EXAMPLE 1 - WIND LOAD ON PIPERACK Design a piperack in Uthmaniyah Gas Plant. The pipe rack case shall be as shown in Figure 1 (Bent spacing = 20 ft), with a 3-second Gust wind speed of 96 mph per SAES-A-112. Design wind forces are determined by the equation per Section 3.5 (repeated below) where F is the force per unit length of the piping or cable tray: F = qz G Cf Ae
ASCE 7 Table 6-1
Design wind pressure, for 30 ft elevation qz = 26.59 psf
(Ref. Table 2 – Attach. 1)
Gust effect factor, G = 0.85
(ASCE 7, Section 6.6.1)
Force Coefficients For structural members For columns For pipes For cable trays
Cf = 1.8 Cf = 2.0 Cf = 0.7 Cf = 2.0
(Ref. Section 4.1) (Ref. Section 4.1) (Ref. Section 4.1.3) (Ref. Section 4.1.4)
Projected Area Projected Area per foot of pipe rack, Ae = Largest pipe diameter or cable tray height + 10% of pipe rack width. (Ref. Sections 4.1.1 and 4.1.2) PART I – PIPING AND CABLE TRAY The guidelines require the consideration of the piping or cable trays separately from the structural members. The following calculations are only for piping and cable trays without the structural support members: Force F1
Calculation
Force (Pounds)
Cable Tray 6” Deep (@ level 30’-0”) Cf = 2.0 Ae = 0.5 + (10% *25 ft) = 3.0 sq ft F1 = qz G Cf Ae F1 = [(26.59 psf)*(0.85) * (2.0) * (3.0)]*20.0 ft bent spacing F1=2712.2 lb. Page 22 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
F2
Pipe Level 25 ft – 24” Max. O.D. Cf = 0.7 Ae = 2.0 + (10% *25 ft) = 4.5 sq ft F2 = qz G Cf Ae F2 = [(26.59 psf)*(0.85) * (0.7) * (4.5)]*20.0 ft bent spacing F2=1423.9 lb.
F3
Pipe Level 20 ft – 18” Max. O.D. Cf = 0.7 Ae = 1.5 + (10% *25 ft) = 4.0 sq ft F3 = qz G Cf Ae F3 = [(26.59 psf)*(0.85) * (0.7) * (4.0)]*20.0 ft bent spacing F3=1265.7 lb.
PART II – STRUCTURAL MEMBERS For structural members, assume 25 ft wide rack with bent spacing of 20 ft centers, all stringers not shielded. Stringers at elevations 30.0, 22.5 and 17.5 (Refer to Figure 1) Assume
qz = 26.59 psf for all 3 levels of stringers (conservative) Cf = 1.8 Ae = 9.73/12 ft (beam depth) * 20 ft (beam length) = 16.22 ft2 F = qz G Cf Ae F4=F5=F6= (26.59 psf) * 0.85 *1.8 * 16.22 ft2 = 660 lb.
Columns qz = 26.59 psf at elev. 30 ft qz = 25.50 psf at elev. 25 ft qz = 24.42 psf at elev. 20 ft Use qz = 26.59 psf for the whole column (conservative) Cf = 2.0 Ae = 8/12 ft (column width) * 1 ft = 0.67 ft2/linear foot F = qz G Cf Ae Force per column F = (26.59 psf) * 0.85 * 2.0 * 0.67 = 30.3 lb / ft For piperack wind load values on the bent, refer to Figures 1 & 1A below: Page 23 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
WIND LOAD ON PIPES & STEEL MEMBERS 6” Conduit Racks
F 1
F4
F 4
W 10 x 33 24” O.D. Max.
5’-0” F2 3 ft F5
W 12 x 40
5’-0”
F5
18” O.D. Max.
2.5’
F3 5 ft F6
W 12 x 45
F6
2.5’
W 10 x 33 TYP. d = 9.73”
30’-0”
20’-0” W 14 x 53
W 14 x 53
bf = 8”
EL 0.00 30.3 #/ft
Figure 1
25’-0” 30.3 #/ft
Typical Bent Example 1 Page 24 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
2712# 660#
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
WIND LOAD ON PIPES & STRUCTURE 660# W 10 x 33
5’-0” 1424# 5’-0”
W 12 x 40
660#
660# 2’-6”
1266# W 12 x 45
660#
660#
2’-6”
30’-0”
20’-0” W 14 x 53
W 14 x 53
30.3 #/ft
Figure 1A
25’-0”
30.3 #/ft
Typical Bent Example 1 Attach. 2 Page 25 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Attachment 3 EXAMPLE 2 - WIND LOAD ON PIPERACK The piperack case shall be as shown in Figure 2 (bent spacing = 20 ft), with a 3-second Gust wind speed of 103 mph. Design wind forces are determined by the equation per Section 3.5 (repeated below) where F is the force per unit length of the piping or cable tray: F = qz G Cf Ae
ASCE 7 Table 6-1
Design wind pressure, for 35 ft elevation qz = 31.55 psf
(Ref. Table 2 – Attach. 1)
Gust effect factor, G = 0.85
(ASCE 7, Section 6.6.1)
Force Coefficients For structural members For columns For pipes For cable trays
Cf = 1.8 Cf = 2.0 Cf = 0.7 Cf = 2.0
(Ref. Section 4.1) (Ref. Section 4.1) (Ref. Section 4.1.3) (Ref. Section 4.1.4)
Projected Area Projected Area per foot of pipe rack, Ae = Largest pipe diameter or cable tray height + 10% of pipe rack width. (Ref. Sections 4.1.1 and 4.1.2) PART I – PIPING AND CABLE TRAY The guidelines require the consideration of the piping or cable trays separately from the structural members. The following calculations are only for piping and cable trays without the structural support members: Force F1
Calculation
Force (Pounds)
Cable Tray 6” Deep (@ elev. 35’-0”) Cf = 2.0 Ae = 0.5 + (10% *20 ft) = 2.5 sq ft F1 = qz G Cf Ae F1= [(31.55 psf) * (0.85) * (2.0) * (2.5)] * 20.0 ft bent spa. F1 = 2681.8 lb
Page 26 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
F2
Pipe Level 31 ft – 12” Max. O.D. Cf = 0.7 Ae = 1.0 + (10% *20 ft) = 3.0 sq ft F2 = qz G Cf Ae F2 = [(30.80 psf) * (0.85) * (0.7) * (3.0)] * 20.0 ft bent spa. F2 = 1100 lb
F3
Pipe Level 27 ft – 20” Max. O.D. Cf = 0.7 Ae = 1.67 + (10% *20 ft) = 3.67 sq ft F3 = qz G Cf Ae F3 = [(29.86 psf) * (0.85) * (0.7) * (3.67)] * 20.0 ft bent spa. F3 = 1304 lb
F4
Pipe Level 21 ft – 30” Max. O.D. Cf = 0.7 Ae = 2.50 + (10% *20 ft) = 4.50 sq ft F4 = qz G Cf Ae F4 = [(28.36 psf) * (0.85) * (0.7) * (4.50)] * 20.0 ft bent spa. F4 = 1519 lb
F5
Pipe Level 15 ft – 24” Max. O.D. Cf = 0.7 Ae = 2.0 + (10% *20 ft) = 4.0 sq ft F5 = qz G Cf Ae F5 = [(26.55 psf) * (0.85) * (0.7) * (4.0)] * 20.0 ft bent spa. F5 = 1264 lb
PART II – STRUCTURAL MEMBERS For structural members, assume 20 ft wide rack with bent spacing of 20 ft centers, all stringers not shielded. Stringers at elevations 35.0, 24.0, 18.0 and 12.5 Cf = 1.8 Ae = 9.73/12 ft (beam depth) * 20 ft (beam length) = 16.22 ft2 F = qz G Cf Ae = qz x 0.85 x 16.22 = qz x 24.82 F6 = 31.55 x 24.82 = 783 lb F7 = 29.11 x 24.82 = 723 lb F8 = 27.49 x 24.82 = 682 lb F9 = 26.55 x 24.82 = 659 lb
Page 27 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Columns qz = 31.55 psf at elev. 35 ft qz = 28.11 psf at elev. 20 ft Use qz = 31.55 psf for 20-35’ column (conservative) Cf = 2.0 Ae = 10/12 ft (column width) * 1 ft = 0.83 ft2/linear foot F = qz G Cf Ae Force per column F = (31.55 psf) * 0.85 * 2.0 * 0.83 = 44.5 pounds / foot Force for 0-20’ = F = 28.11 x 0.85 x 2.0 x 0.83 = 39.7 pounds / foot
Page 28 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
For piperack wind load values on bent, refer to Figures 2 & 2A below: 6” Conduit Racks F1 F6
4’-0”
12”
W 10
20”
W 12
F6
F2
4’-0” F3 F7
6’-0”
F7
W 12 30” O.D. Max
3’
F4 F8
35’-0” 6’-0”
24” O.D. Max
W 10 x 33 TYP.
F5
F8
W 12
W 12
F9
W 14 x 61
3’-0” 3’-0”
F9
2.5’
W 14 x 61
15’-0”
0.0 20 ft
Figure 2
Typical Bent
Page 29 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
2682#
783#
783#
El. 35’-0”
W 10 x 33
4’-0” 1100
44.5 # / ft
4’-0”
W 12 x 40 1304
W 12 x 40
722
6’-0”
722
3’-0”
1519
35’-0”
W 12 x 40
682
6’-0” 1264
3’-0” 3’-0”
W 10 x 33 TYP.
W 12 x 45
6593
W 14 x 61
15’-0”
682
El. 20’-0’
659
2’-6” 39.7 # / ft
W 14 x 61
bf = 10”
El. 0’-0” 20’-0” #
39.7 /ft
Figure 2A
Typical Bent Example 2 Attach. 3 Page 30 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Attachment 4 EXAMPLE 3 3.0
WIND LOAD ON OPEN FRAME STRUCTURE
The plan and elevation views of the structure are shown in Figures 3.1, 3.2 and 3.3. The structure considered is 40 ft (12.19 m) x 40 ft (12.19 m) x 82 ft (24.99 m) high, with three open frames in the direction of wind. The basic wind speed V = 119 mph. This is a 3-second gust wind speed with an annual probability of exceeding of 0.02. Member sizes are assumed as follows: Columns Beams at El. 20’-0’’ (6.10 m) Beams at El. 48’-0” (14.63 m) Beams at El. 82’-0” (24.99 m) Braces Intermediate Beams
-
12 in x 12 in (0.31 m x 0.31 m) W36 W18 W18 W8 W12
Design wind forces are determined by the Equation 4.1a (Sect. 4.2.2) Fs = qz G Cf Ae
ASCE 7 Table 6-1 (Eq. 4.1a)
where Fs is the wind force on structural frame and appurtenance It is convenient to determine the velocity pressures at the mid-floor heights and at the top of the structure. Table 3.1 below summarizes qz values at various levels: Table 3.1 Velocity Pressure qz Height above Ground z (ft) 10 34 65 h = 83
*qz (psf) 36.0 42.4 48.8 51.7
Note: To convert psf to N/m2 multiply values in this table by 47.878 *qz is obtained from Table 1 – Attachment 1 Although the top of the third floor level is at 82 ft, the structure height “h” is increased slightly to account for the handrail on top of the structure (see Figures 3.2 and 3.3). Page 31 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
The gust effect factor is determined next. The ratio of height / least horizontal dimension = 83 ft / 41 ft = 2.02 < 4, therefore the structure is not considered a flexible structure. Use Gust effect factor, G = 0.85 3.1
(ASCE 7, Section 6.6.1)
ALONG WIND FORCE CALCULATIONS
In order to calculate the force coefficient, the solidity ratio ε must first be computed from Equation 4.3, which stated ε = As / Ag. The gross area (or envelope area) is the area within the outmost projections of the front face normal to the nominal wind direction. Note that the width used below is measured from outside column face to outside column face. For the wind direction shown in Figure 3.1, Ag = 83 ft (height) x 41 ft (width) = 3,403 ft2 (316 m2) To determine the effective solid area, the solid area of the windward frame must first be calculated per 4.2.4.a. In order to facilitate the computation of forces later in the problem, it is convenient to calculate the solid areas from mid-floor to mid-floor, and sum these to obtain the total solid area of the frame. Calculation of solid area of the windward frame (column line 3) is summarized in Table 3.2. The stairs are considered as part of the windward frame (see Figure 3.1). The stairs column in Table 3.2 includes area of stair stringer, struts, handrails, and bracing. TABLE 3.2 Solid Area of Windward Frame - As Floor Tributary Level Height (ft) 0 0-10 1 10-34 2 34-65 3 65-83
Solid Areas (ft2) Cols. Beams Interm. Bracing Handrails Beams 30 0 0 19 0 72 120 40 40 32 93 60 80 38 40 51 60 40 38 40 Total Solid Area of Windward Frame (ft2) =
Stairs
Total
76 150 91 17
125 454 402 236 1217 ft2
Note: To convert ft2 to m2 multiply values in this table by 0.0929 Since the middle and leeward frames (column lines 2 and 1, respectively) are similar to the windward frame with the exception of not having stairs, the solid areas and hence the solidity ratios for these two frames will be less than the windward frame, so As is equal to the solid area of windward frame per 4.2.4.d, which leads to ε = As / Ag = 1,217 ft2 / 3,403 ft2 = 0.358
Page 32 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Next, the coefficient CDg is obtained from curves given in Figure 4.1 as a function of the solidity ratio ε, the number of frames N, and the frame spacing ratio SF/B. As defined in Figure 4.1, N=3 and SF/B= 20 ft / 41 ft = 0.488. From Figures 4.1c & 4.1d, for N = 3 and extrapolating slightly for ε = 0.358 CDg = 1.09, for SF/B= 0.5 CDg = 1.03, for SF/B= 0.33 Interpolating for SF/B= 0.488, CDg =1.03 + (1.09 –1.03)[(0.488-0.33) / (0.50-0.33)] = 1.086 Next, the gross area force coefficient CDg is converted into a force coefficient compatible with ASCE 7 by means of Equation 4.2. Cf = CDg / ε = 1.086 / 0.358 = 3.03 The area of application of force Ae has already been determined per floor level during calculation of solidity ratio. The wind force transmitted to each floor level may now be found by Equation 4-1a, F = qz G Cf Ae as shown below. The total force on the structural frame and appurtenances Fs is 143.1 kips (639.9 kN), found by summing the forces at all levels in Table 3.3. TABLE 3.3 Total Force – Structural Frame and Appurtenances - Fs Floor Level 0 1 2 3
qz (psf) 36.0 42.4 48.8 51.7
G
Cf
0.85 0.85 0.85 0.85
3.03 3.03 3.03 3.03
Ae (ft2) 125 454 402 236 Fs = ΣF =
F (lbs) 11,590 49,577 50,525 31,424 143,116
Note: To convert pounds force (lbs) to newtons (N) multiply F values in this table by 4.448 These forces are due to wind acting on the frames only. Wind forces acting on the vessels, equipment and piping are computed separately. Wind loads on vessels, equipment and piping are not in the scope of this guideline (Refer to Sections 4.1 and 4.3 of the ASCE reference “Wind Loads and Anchor Bolt Design for Petrochemical Facilities” for requirements). 3.2
CROSSWIND FORCE CALCULATIONS
The next step is to repeat the analysis for the nominal wind direction normal to column line A (see Figures 3.1 and 3.3) – “non-windward” frame. The member sizes are the same on this elevation except that the intermediate beams are W10’s and Page 33 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
Beams at El. 20’-0”
- W14
Beams at El. 48’-0”
- W16
Beams at El. 82’-0”
- W12
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
The gross area of the windward face includes the stair tower on the right hand side of the structure. Ag = (83 x 41) + (9 x 49) = 3,844 ft2 The solid areas for the windward frame are given below. The stairs column in the table includes areas of the stair column, struts, and handrails (see Table 3.4). TABLE 3.4 Solid Area - As Floor Tributary Level Height (ft) 0 0-10 1 10-34 2 34-65 3 65-83
Solid Areas (ft2) Cols. Beams Interm. Bracing Handrails Beams 30 0 0 19 0 72 46 8 35 40 93 53 41 36 40 51 40 0 16 40 Total Solid Area of Windward Frame (ft2) =
Stairs 24 44 36 0
Total 73 245 299 147 764 ft2
Note: To convert ft2 to m2 multiply As values in this table by 0.0929 Since the solidity of neither the middle and leeward frames (column lines B and C, respectively) exceeds that of the windward frame, As is equal to the solid area of windward frame, yielding ε = As / Ag = 764 ft2 / 3,844 ft2 = 0.199 The frame spacing ratio in this direction is SF/B = 20 ft / 46 ft = 0.435. Since the width is not uniform (the stair tower stops at the second floor level), an average value of B is used. From Figures 4.1c & 4.1d for N=3 and ε = 0.199 CDg = 0.72, for SF/B= 0.5 CDg = 0.71, for SF/B= 0.33 Therefore use CDg = 0.716 Cf = CDg / ε = 0.716 / 0.199 = 3.60 Page 34 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
The wind forces per floor level are shown in Table 3.5 TABLE 3.5 Total Force – Structural Frame and Appurtenance - Fs Floor Level 0 1 2 3
qz (psf) 36.0 42.4 48.8 51.7
G
Cf
0.85 0.85 0.85 0.85
3.60 3.60 3.60 3.60
Ae (ft2) 73 245 299 147 Fs = ΣF =
F (lbs) 8,042 31,787 44,649 23,256 107,734
Note: To convert pounds force (lbs) to newtons (N) multiply F values in this table by 4.448 3.3
Open Frame Example – Summary and Conclusion The results thus far are summarized in the Table 3.6. The load combinations for design are application of FT in one direction simultaneously with 0.5 Fs in the other, per 4.2.6.1. These combinations are shown in Figure 3.4. TABLE 3.6 Summary Wind Load on FS Structural Frame Wind Load on FE Equipment And Piping Total Wind Load on FT Structure
Wind – Direction 1 143 kips (636 kN)
Wind – Direction 2 108 kips (480 kN)
*Assume 27 kips (120 kN) 170 kips (756 kN)
*Assume 19 kips (84.5 kN) 127 kips (565 kN)
*No equipment or piping were included in this example, but for illustration purpose, assume that horizontal vessels and piping were included and the wind loads are as shown in the Table.
Page 35 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Adapted from ASCE “ Wind Loads and Anchor Bolt Design for Petrochemical Facilities”
Page 36 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Adapted from ASCE “ Wind Loads and Anchor Bolt Design for Petrochemical Facilities”
Page 37 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Adapted from ASCE “ Wind Loads and Anchor Bolt Design for Petrochemical Facilities”
Page 38 of 39
Document Responsibility: Onshore Structures Issue Date: 31 August, 2002 Next Update: 1 September, 2007
SABP-M-006 Wind Loads on Piperacks and Open Frame Structures
Adapted from ASCE “ Wind Loads and Anchor Bolt Design for Petrochemical Facilities”
Page 39 of 39
